DOS ain't dead - University Challenge

University Challenge (Announce)

posted by tkchia , 26.03.2022, 00:04

Hello kerravon,

> I didn't use the phrase "more competitive". Why
> don't you quote something I actually said? I'm
> not sure what that actually means.

Well, here is what I mean: you are claiming that a BSD License or an MIT License will somehow prevent a piece of code from becoming the nucleus of a "Microsoft competitor", but if the code were public domain, then suddenly good things will magically happen and the code will magically become a "Microsoft competitor".

Did I get you right?

> > We have seen
> >
> what
> > happens when for-profit companies rely on code written by
> volunteers
> > without paying back anything in kind.
>
> That is a problem with copyrighted freeware. What
> I am interested in is a company picking up some
> public domain code as a BASE, something that "mostly
> works", and then taking ownership of it, making sure
> it passes their own stringent tests (the sort of
> effort you are alluding to with "paying back"), and
> then commercially protecting that by making it closed
> source, and stamping their own reputation on it.

And what makes you so sure they would they do that?

No company decided to "take ownership" of the OpenSSL code. This, even though any one company could easily do so.

Why do you expect that, if OpenSSL were public domain, then some company would magically decide to maintain it properly, rather than leaving the project in its under-funded state?

You are just engaging in hand-waving and wishful thinking here.

> "everyone" doesn't speak with one voice.

You do not realize that this works both ways? Perhaps you should stop being enamoured with your own voice?

Thank you!

---
https://gitlab.com/tkchia · https://codeberg.org/tkchia · 😴 "MOV AX,0D500H+CMOS_REG_D+NMI"

Post reply

Complete thread:

University Challenge - kerravon, 20.03.2022, 18:14 (Announce)
- University Challenge - tom, 21.03.2022, 21:39
  - University Challenge - kerravon, 21.03.2022, 22:17
    - University Challenge - glennmcc, 22.03.2022, 19:06
      - University Challenge - tkchia, 22.03.2022, 20:59
        University Challenge - kerravon, 22.03.2022, 23:09
        University Challenge - tkchia, 23.03.2022, 22:13
        University Challenge - kerravon, 25.03.2022, 21:39
        University Challenge - tkchia, 25.03.2022, 22:04
        University Challenge - kerravon, 25.03.2022, 22:17
        University Challenge - tkchia, 25.03.2022, 22:40
        University Challenge - kerravon, 25.03.2022, 23:55
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 00:04
        University Challenge - kerravon, 26.03.2022, 00:49
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 07:03
        University Challenge - kerravon, 26.03.2022, 07:59
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 08:18
        University Challenge - kerravon, 26.03.2022, 09:26
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 09:35
        University Challenge - kerravon, 26.03.2022, 12:35
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 26.03.2022, 19:53
        University Challenge - ecm, 26.03.2022, 20:44
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 26.03.2022, 21:02
        University Challenge - ecm, 26.03.2022, 22:09
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 26.03.2022, 23:23
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 01:05
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 08:01
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 08:39
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 09:01
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 10:58
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 11:13
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 11:28
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 11:26
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 11:34
        University Challenge - tom, 27.03.2022, 13:35
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 14:05
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 27.03.2022, 19:24
        University Challenge - tom, 27.03.2022, 19:47
        University Challenge - kerravon, 28.03.2022, 00:48
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 28.03.2022, 03:37
        University Challenge - kerravon, 28.03.2022, 08:29
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 28.03.2022, 18:38
        University Challenge - kerravon, 28.03.2022, 19:09
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 27.03.2022, 14:40
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 08:43
        University Challenge - marcov, 27.03.2022, 17:59
        University Challenge - kerravon, 27.03.2022, 23:15
        University Challenge - marcov, 28.03.2022, 07:42
        University Challenge - kerravon, 28.03.2022, 08:34
        University Challenge - tkchia, 27.03.2022, 07:43
        University Challenge - Stop this - ecm, 26.03.2022, 12:00
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 00:15
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 25.03.2022, 23:37
        University Challenge - kerravon, 26.03.2022, 00:02
        University Challenge - tkchia, 26.03.2022, 07:06
        University Challenge - marcov, 26.03.2022, 11:33
        University Challenge - glennmcc, 26.03.2022, 20:28
      - University Challenge (using SubC compiler) - Rugxulo, 27.03.2022, 18:45
        University Challenge (using SubC compiler) - kerravon, 28.03.2022, 00:42
        ISO 7185 Pascal (p5, p5c) -- public domain - Rugxulo, 09.04.2022, 04:07
        ISO 7185 Pascal (p5, p5c) -- public domain - marcov, 09.04.2022, 12:36